Theory board · evidence required

A theory is a question with receipts

A safe home for fan ideas without allowing speculation, leaked material or unverified casting to become accidental canon.

Reviewed guide · Sources & corrections

State it narrowly

One proposition that could be supported, weakened or disproved.

Attach evidence

Link supporting and conflicting observations to episode or evidence records.

Name assumptions

Identify every step the programme has not confirmed.

Define a test

State what future evidence would change the theory’s status.

No approved public theories yet

An unanswered question is not automatically a theory. Entries will appear only after their evidence, counter-evidence and spoiler level have been reviewed.

Propose a theory for editorial review →
ActiveCompatible with current evidenceWeakenedImportant evidence conflictsDisprovedBroadcast canon rules it outConfirmedThe programme establishes it

Evidence rule

No private-life claims, leaked production material or unaired solutions are accepted. Every published entry must include evidence for and against.

Casebook index

Search the archive

224 results